Skip to main content

Living in Marco Island brings plenty of beauty and fun things to do. While entertaining friends and family in the comfortable, open spaces of your Gulfstream Home is a pleasure, you will certainly want to venture out and explore our charming area. Whether you have finished a day playing golf with friends or enjoyed a relaxing day on the water, you might be looking for a great place to stop for food and drinks. This local’s guide will help you find the best restaurants in Marco Island, FL.

1. Davinci’s

The first restaurant on our list is Davinci’s, which is a stunning Italian style restaurant that is the perfect location for a special celebration or just a nice evening out. Founded by the Carvelli family, it has a charming ambiance that will remind you of a beautiful trip to Italy without having to worry about the travel time.

Every person that steps foot into the restaurant will feel like family and enjoy a great selection of signature dishes that stem from northern, central, and southern Italian cuisine. They also offer an incredible selection of wines, which makes it a great choice for stopping in with loved ones.

Their menu includes an array of delicious Italian dishes including:

  • Campagnola and Prosciutto pizzas
  • Spaghetti Con Polpette
  • Pollo Romano
  • Gnocchi Alla Sorrentina
  • Ravioli Di Formaggio

2. Marco Prime Steaks and Seafood

Marco Prime Steaks and Seafood is a great place to enjoy a delicious meal in the heart of Marco Island. Their modern atmosphere has a unique taste on a classic steakhouse with hints of French, Italian, and Asian cuisines.

Not only do they serve incredible steaks, but they also have an excellent selection of seafood along with hand-crafted cocktails and an abundant wine selection. Their steaks are American Black Angus Hi Choice & Prime Steaks which feature Australian Wagyu Beef to provide the best flavor possible. When it comes to their seafood they have fish that is received daily in the restaurant from around the world and prepared by highly skilled chefs.

3. Doreen’s Cup of Joe

For a more relaxed atmosphere, but still some of the best food in Marco Island, you should plan to make a stop at Doreen’s Cup of Joe. They are only open for breakfast and lunch, but boast a menu that is sure to make your stomach happy!

They are proud to offer local and specially sourced ingredients including cage free brown eggs, sausage patties from a local country store in Tallahassee, milk products from a farm in Myakka City, and premium coffee from a local roaster.

Their menu includes items such as omelets, skillets, breakfast sandwiches, waffles, french toast, and homemade donut holes for breakfast as well as sandwiches, salads, and burgers for lunch.

4. The Oyster Society

Named as a must-stop when in Marco Island, you must try The Oyster Society. Owned by the same family as Davinci’s, this restaurant is known to have some of the best seafood around. The restaurant is located in one of the best locations in Marco Island and within walking distance to some of the top resorts.

Their menu includes almost any type of seafood you could want including oysters, sea scallops, shrimp, salmon, sushi, sea bass, and lobster along with an incredible drink and dessert menu. It is worth your time to stop in!

Best Restaurants in Marco Island

No matter what kind of food you are looking for, Marco Island has incredible restaurants that are worth stopping into! Be sure to let us know if you enjoy any of the restaurants mentioned above.

Gulfstream Homes is ready to help you build a home on Marco Island! Call (239) 254-1664 or visit to get started.